Captain William Kidd (uncredited)

Stanley Andrews

Acting

Captain of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)

Wade Boteler

Acting

Pirate (uncredited)

James Dime

Acting

Narrator (voice) (uncredited)

Leslie Fenton

Acting

Pirate (uncredited)

Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian

Acting

First Mate Palmer (uncredited)

Charles Irwin

Acting

Member of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)

Edward LeSaint

Acting

Pirate (uncredited)

Jack Roper

Acting

Member of Captain Kidd's Crew (uncredited)

Charles Sullivan

Acting

Skeptical Member of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)

Ian Wolfe

Acting