William 'Billy the Kid' Bonney

Scott Brady

Acting

Nita Maxwell

Betta St. John

Acting

Pat Garrett

James Griffith

Acting

Bob Ollinger

Alan Hale Jr.

Acting

John H. Tunstall

Paul Cavanagh

Acting

Charley Bowdre

William Phillips

Acting

Arnold Dodge

Benny Rubin

Acting

Sheriff Tom Watkins

Steve Darrell

Acting

Tom O'Folliard

George Berkeley

Acting

Dave Rudabaugh

William Tannen

Acting

Pete Maxwell (as Richard Cutting)

Richard H. Cutting

Acting