Kim Diamond

Kim Director

Acting

Jeffrey "Jeff" Patterson

Jeffrey Donovan

Acting

Erica Geerson

Erica Leerhsen

Acting

Tristen Ryler

Tristine Skyler

Acting

Stephen Ryan Parker

Stephen Barker Turner

Acting

Sheriff Cravens

Lanny Flaherty

Acting

Eileen Treacle

Lauren Hulsey

Acting

Rustin Parr

Raynor Scheine

Acting

Peggy

Kennen Sisco

Acting

Reporter

Dina Napoli

Acting

Burkittsville Tourist

Joe Berlinger

Directing

MBI Man

Pete Burris

Acting

Stoner

Briton Green

Acting

Tourist

Anja Baron

Acting

Kurt Loder

Kurt Loder

Acting

Chuck Scarborough

Chuck Scarborough

Acting

Self (archive footage)

Conan O'Brien

Acting

Self (archive footage)

Andy Richter

Acting

Burkittsville Resident #1

Bruce D. Reed

Acting

Burkittsville Tourist #2

Sara Phillips

Acting

Burkittsville Resident #2

Lynda Millard

Acting

Burkittsville Resident #3

Deb Burgoyne

Acting

Burkittsville Resident #4

Andrea Cox

Acting

Stoner #2

Erik Jensen

Acting

Foreigner #1

Peggy K. Chang

Acting

Foreigner #2

Tony Tsang

Acting

Doctor

Kevin Murray

Acting

Nurse

Keira Naughton

Acting

MBI Man #2

Ed Sala

Acting

Teenager #1

Tyler Zeisloft

Acting

Teenager #2

Richard Kirkwood

Acting

Teenager #3

Justin Fair

Production

Ham Lady

Brilane Bowman

Acting

MBI Man #3

Robert M. Kelly

Acting

Reporter, Fox 45

Landra Booker

Acting

Reporter

Jacqui Allen

Art

Reporter, WJZ 13

Sloane Brown

Acting

(voice)

Karen Tsen Lee

Acting

Print Reporter

Heidi Burger

Acting

Angry Citizen at Courthouse

Brian Dragonuk

Acting

Doctor

Armen Garo

Acting

Security Guard

Nasi Glekas

Acting

First Nurse

Cathy Haase

Acting

Videographer

Oscar Haynes

Acting

On Camera News Reporter

Rick Kain

Crew

Hiker in Woods

Julie Mabry

Acting

Mental Patient

Martin Pfefferkorn

Acting

Photographer

Chad Ridgely

Acting

Ryan Slattery

Acting

Heather Donahue (archive footage) (uncredited)

Heather Donahue

Acting

Joshua Leonard (archive footage) (uncredited)

Joshua Leonard

Acting

Michael Williams (archive footage) (uncredited)

Michael C. Williams

Acting

Teenager #3

Justin Fair

Acting